Why Do We Feel Guilty When We Rest?

22 Nov 2024

Nicola Spencer

nicola.spencer@strongcounselling.com

Guilt: according to the dictionary, is “the fact or state of having committed an offense, crime, violation, or wrong, especially against moral or penal law.” In other words, guilt is tied to the idea of doing something truly wrong—something harmful or offensive. So, why is it that so many of us feel guilty when we take time off to rest? When we say no to yet another obligation? When we simply stop for a moment to breathe?

It’s almost as if society has taught us to believe that committing actual crimes or violations is somehow synonymous with rest and self-care. Let that sink in. Resting—something essential for health and well-being—is often treated as an act worthy of guilt or shame. How did we get here!?

Guilt: An Emotion Imposed from the Outside In

It’s important to recognize that the guilt we feel around rest is not necessarily something that’s self-derived. Rather, it’s a feeling that we’ve been taught to feel. Modern culture celebrates productivity, often linking our worth to what we produce and how much we accomplish. We’re encouraged to believe that every moment we aren’t “achieving something” is a moment wasted.

So when that familiar pang of guilt arises during rest, ask yourself: Where is this really coming from? Chances are, it’s not your voice; it’s an echo of a society that’s normalized endless busyness as a measure of success. By seeing this guilt for what it is—an external message—we can begin to separate it from our true feelings and challenge it.

Recognizing the Real Difference Between Guilt and Rest

When we clearly understand the difference between true guilt and the perceived guilt surrounding rest, we can start to dismantle that ingrained shame. True guilt is a reaction to something wrong—an action that actually hurts someone, violates trust, or crosses boundaries. Rest, on the other hand, doesn’t harm anyone; it helps. Rest recharges us, allowing us to show up more fully in our lives, relationships, and work.

By seeing rest as a benefit rather than a detriment, we give ourselves permission to exist without that guilty shadow hanging over our heads. And in doing so, we slowly liberate ourselves from this burdensome, unjustified guilt.

It’s Not a “You” Thing

Breaking free from the “guilt of rest” mindset sounds simple, but it’s not exactly easy to do… Because we’re essentially challenging an entire lifetime of ingrained beliefs that reward constant achievement and perfectionism. So I fully get that this is much easier said than done!!

But remember, you are not the problem here. By choosing to rest, you are:

  • NOT falling behind: Progress includes time for recovery.
  • NOT failing: Success doesn’t require nonstop action.
  • NOT missing out: Rest is its own valuable experience and often a necessary precursor to meaningful engagement.

You’re simply resting, recharging, and being present.

A Final Thought: Reclaiming Rest as a Form of Self-Compassion

Reframing guilt around rest is an act of self-compassion and self-awareness. Rest is not a crime or a violation—it’s a right. It’s a form of self-respect. By recognizing and rejecting the misplaced guilt around rest, we take a small but powerful step towards redefining what “success” truly means and allowing ourselves to feel at peace in the process.

So the next time you feel guilty for resting, try a gentle reminder: this guilt is not yours to carry. By choosing rest, you’re choosing a healthier, more balanced way to live—and there’s no guilt in that (or at least, there shouldn’t be).

I’ve worked with a lot of perfectionists & have carried the identity for myself. I know how hard it can be to remove the negative feelings we associate with taking time off. And I’d love to help you discover how therapy might support you in your pursuit of rest, growth and mental health. 

Reach out to Strong Counselling to book a consultation with me.

We're here to help

Strong Counselling

"*" indicates required fields